资源描述：
《外研社杯辩论赛辩题分析.doc》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。
1、THWcreateandenforcefilialresponsibilitylaws.2017-12-22 思辨精英平台THWcreateandenforcefilialresponsibilitylaws.·ProblemsExistingintheStatusQuo·-Proposition- 1. OnechildpolicyinChinamakesparentsputalotofeffortsuponchildren,butchildrendon’tpaybackcorrespondingly,thusalotofparentsarebeingleftover.
2、 2. Lackofwell-establishednursinghousesfortheelderlyinthesociety. 3. Parentshavestereotypicalideatowardsnursinghousesandahighexpectationontheirchildren,thustheyarenotwillingtogothere. -Opposition- 1. Childrenliveinfamilieswhicharerandomlydeterminedbybirthlottery,someofthemevenliveinacoerc
3、ivefamilycondition. 2. Familyemotionalbondisenough,thereisnonecessityforthispolicy,thusgovernmentsidedoesn’thavetogothatfarbymakingitintoalaw.·Possiblemodel· MakefilialresponsibilitylawsaCivillaw,oncechildrenviolated,theywouldbesuedandfined,themonetaryresponsibilityrequiresthemoneytheygiv
4、etheirparentsshouldbeproportionatetothesalaryorthemoneytheirparentshavespentonthembefore;thecaringresponsibilityrequiresanationalizedquotaaboutthetimechildrenshouldspendwiththeirparents.·Argumentsforproposition· 1. Havingchildrenwillcostalotforparents,thuschildrenshouldshoulderresponsibi
5、lityafterwardsandthelawenforcementisreasonable:raisingchildrenrequiresparentstotakethemasuppermostpriority,thentheywillsacrificealotofopportunities,makesthemlesscompetitiveanddetertheirself-actualizationprocess,andalsoconsideringthehugeexpendituretheyspendwhenraisetheirchildren,itislegiti
6、matetohavealawtoprotectparentswhentheyareinvulnerablepositions. 2. Havingchildrenmakesthegenderroleprobleminthesocietyevenmoreseverethuschildrenshouldcompensateforthat:havingchildrenmeansfemaleshavetosuffermorediscriminationoutofmaternalleave,andmalesmustshouldermoreresponsibility,expecta
7、tionandpressurefromsociety. 3. Thispolicywillpromotepositivediscourseinpublic,letchildrenreconsidertheirroleandrealizetheignorancetheyhavetowardsparents,influencethechildrenwhoaren’twillingtotakecareoftheirparentsinprevioustime,spendmoretimewiththeirparents.Positiv
