论文申辩的心得分享 论文申辩的心得分享 黄迪靖.pdf

《论文申辩的心得分享 论文申辩的心得分享 黄迪靖.pdf》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在应用文档-天天文库。

1、論文申辯的心得分享黃迪靖Donotupsetorpanicwhenyourmanuscriptisrejected.•Itiscommonthatpapersarerejectedinthefirstrun.Re:LF10693Charge‐orbitalorderinginmagnetitemeasuredbyresonantsoftx‐rayscatteringbyD.J.Huang,H.‐J.Lin,J.Okamoto,K.S.Chao,H.‐T.Jeng,etal.DearDr.Huang,Theabovemanuscripthasbee

2、nreviewedbyoneofourreferees.Acritiquedrawnfromthereportisenclosed.Onthisbasis,wejudgethatthepaperisnotappropriateforPhysicalReviewLetters,butmightbesuitableforpublicationinanotherjournal,possiblywithsomerevision.Therefore,werecommendthatyousubmityourmanuscriptelsewhere.Yourss

3、incerely,SamindranathMitraAssociateEditorPhysicalReviewLettersEmail:prl@ridge.aps.orgFax:631‐591‐4141http://prl.aps.org/Donotupsetorpanicwhenyourmanuscriptisrejected.•Itiscommonthatpapersarerejectedinthefirstrun.•Forexample,lessthan35%ofsubmittedpapershavebeenfinallyacceptedf

4、orpublicationinPhysicalReviewLetters.•Readtherefereereportcarefullyanddispassionately.•Approachthereportwithanopenmind;therefereemightbehelpingyou.Whyisyourpaperrejected?Whorejectsyourpaper,editororref?feree?•OOcayfficiallytetheedtoseditorsrejectyourpaper.Infact……Writingthere

5、buttal.•Clearlyresponsetoallrecommendationsandcriticismsofthereferee.•Point‐by‐pointresponsesarestronglysuggested.•Itisnotwisetosaytherefereeiswrong;Iwouldsay“incorrect”iftherefereewerewrong.•Examplesandreferencesarehelpful.•Supplementmaterialssuchasderivationsorgraphicillust

6、rationsareuseful.•Consultyourcolleagues.Revisingthemanuscript.•Properlyaddresstheref’feree’squestionandclarifyanyambiguity.•Putyourselfinthepositionofareader,whichisexactlythepositionofagoodreferee.Resubmittingthemanuscript.•Coverletter+Summaryofchanges+Replytothereferee.•Con

7、vincetheeditorstosendthepaperoutforreview.•Explainwhichchangeshavebeenmadeandstateyourpositiononpointsofdisagreement.感謝陳正弦、郭光宇、牟中瑜…….謝謝您!