英语BP辩论反方二辩辩论稿.doc

《英语BP辩论反方二辩辩论稿.doc》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在行业资料-天天文库。

1、反方二辩：Thankyou,Mr.（Ms.）speaker.Ladiesandgentlemen,goodevening!Inthefirstpartofmyspeech,Iwouldliketomakemyrebuttal.Thepropseemtothinkthey'reprovidingextraincentivestoscientistsfromuniversitiesandresearchinstitutions,thereforeincreasinginnovation.Thisiswrong.Firstly,manyscientistsworkforpharmaceu

2、ticalcompaniesdirectly.Secondly,scientistsatuniversitiesandresearchinstitutionsarepaidbypharmaceuticalcompaniestoundertakeresearchforthem.Whyisthisimportant?Itmeansthatscientistsareactuallyharmedundertheproposition'smodel,nothelped.Whenpatentsareremoved,pharmaceuticalcompaniescannolongerearnmo

3、nopolyprofits.NowI’dliketoprovidemystatements.Forthefirstaspect,whywesavemorelives?Firstly,underourplanyoucanpayscientistsdoublethebonusestheygetpaidandstillgetthejobdonewaybelowthecurrentcost.Thisisbecausewewon’thavetopay$6-10millionayearfortheCEOofthefirminquestionorbillionsinpublicity.We’re

4、alsoprovidingincentivesforthesamecompaniestoresearchnoveldrugs.Ratherthanfretoverpricesremaininghighfor20yearstomakeaprofitwe'reallowingthemagenerousresearchanddevelopment-linkedprofitondelivery.Secondly,wehavethepreposterousclaimthatuniversityresearchisfundedbycorporations!ThePharmaceuticalRe

5、searchandManufacturersofAmerica,anindustrylobbygroup,estimatesthatprivateindustryfinancesonlyabout43%ofdrugdevelopment!Ourplanallowsforuniversitiesandgovernmentinstitutionstotakeonmoreresearchandevenprovidethemwithconcretebenefits.Thirdly,morethan69%ofthosewithHIVlackaccesstothemedicationtotre

6、atit.Ratherthanpaythecurrentpricesforthat69%foraslongastheyneedthemwhatwedoispayfortheminadrasticallycheaperone-offpaymentthatwouldallowforgenericcopiestobemadeadinfinite.Thiswaywealsodon'tendorsecurrentpracticethatactivelydiscouragesinnovationbutinsteadcreateanewregimethattrulyrewardsitallowi

7、ngeveryonetobenefitfromgenuinelynoveldrugs.Fourthly,theopphasarguedourplanwouldnotencouragecheaperdrugswiththesameeffectstobeproduced.Ofcoursenot!Ifwecreategenericdrugs,accessibletoallwhyneeda“new”drugthatdoesexactlythesame?Thisiswhatha