资源描述：
《哈佛大学公开课Justice-What's the right thing to do 12》由会员上传分享，免费在线阅读，更多相关内容在学术论文-天天文库。
1、Justice12DebatingSame-sexMarriage/TheGoodLifeWeendedlasttimetalkingaboutthenarrativeconceptionoftheself.Weweretestingthenarrativeconceptionoftheselfandtheideaofobligationsofsolidarityormembershipthatdidnotflowfromconsent,thatclaimedusforreasonsunrelatedtoacontractoranagreement
2、orachoicewemayhavemade.Andweweredebatingamongourselveswhetherthereareanyobligationsofthiskindorwhetherallapparentobligationsofsolidarityandmembershipcanbetranslatedintoconsentorreciprocityoruniversaldutythatweowepersonsquapersons.Andthentherewerethosewhodefendedtheideaofloyalt
3、yandofpatriotism.Sotheideaofloyaltyandofsolidarityandofmembershipgatheredacertainkindofintuitivemoralforceinourdiscussion.Andthen,asweconcluded,weconsideredwhatseemstobeaprettypowerfulcounterexampletothatidea.Namely,thefilmofthosesouthernsegregationistsinthe1950s.Andtheytalked
4、allabouttheirtraditions,theirhistory,thewayinwhichtheiridentitieswereboundupwiththeirlifehistory.Doyourememberthat?Andwhatflowedfromthathistory,fromthatnarrativesenseofidentityforthosesouthernsegregationists?Theysaidwehavetodefendourwayoflife.Isthisafataloradecisiveobjectionto
5、theideaofthenarrativeconceptionoftheself?That'sthequestionwewereleftwith.WhatIwouldliketodotodayistoadvanceanargumentandseewhatyoumakeofit.Andletmetellyouwhatthatargumentis.Iwouldliketodefendthenarrativeconceptionofthepersonasagainstthevoluntaristconception.Iwouldliketodefendt
6、heideathatthereareobligationsofsolidarityormembership.Then,Iwanttosuggestthattherebeingsuchobligationslendsforcetotheidea,whenweturntojustice,thatargumentsaboutjusticecan'tbedetached,cannotbedetachedafterall,fromquestionsofthegood.ButIwantedtodistinguishtwodifferentwaysinwhich
7、justicemightbetiedtothegoodandargueforoneofthem.Now,thevoluntaristconceptionofthepersonofKantandRawlswesawwaspowerfulandliberating.Afurtherappealisitsuniversalaspiration.Justice12DebatingSame-sexMarriage/TheGoodLife1Theideaoftreatingpersonsaspersonswithoutprejudice,withoutdisc
8、rimination,andIthinkthat'swhatledsomeamongustoarguethat,okay,
